Wednesday, February 18, 2009

The Golden Compass (PG)

6 comments:

Rebekah said...

Cameron - they are making a He-Man movie. It's called Masters of the Universe and it's scheduled to come out in 2011. It's probably a little sad that I know this, but I don't care, I'm super excited for this movie. :)

Rach said...

If they're going with He-Man, let's do Thundercats, too! I agreed with John on this one, but I'm also a fantasy watcher/reader (sort of--I will never read all the Wheel of Time books, and won't go see all 30 movies when they make them, either), so I guess I'm willing to accept the fantastic. So, where do superhero movies fit in? Cameron, do you consider them fantasy, too? And have you guys done any reviews on the Lord of the Rings movies? I didn't see them on your list. I'm curious about what you'd say to those.

Anonymous said...

I like sci-fi, but I don't like sci-fi people or at least the sci-fi people who are completely unwilling to accept reality and name their cats after Harry Potter characters. Sci-fi exists for the same reason that movies exist - we crave, on some level, fantasy. We crave to escape our daily existence for a couple of hours and live outside of our senses. You only start running into trouble when you forget to return to reality...and also when you've had three cats named Dumbledore one, two and three.

And I liked this movie. I thought it had an interesting concept and a really smart, brassy young female lead which isn't always the case in movies marketed for kids. (Although current films seem to be improving on that.) I knew full well about the controversy surrounding this film and about the ban made on the film by the Catholic church. My father is an atheist and my mother is a Christian - I was raised under both sets of beliefs and am grateful for it. To me, the anger with which the author of these books lashes out towards people of faith is not much different than the anger often thrown at atheists by people of faith. Anger is anger. As a Christian mother raising a Christian child, I am constantly monitoring everything my child watches - just as my atheist father did for me. And just as my dad did for us, I don't allow my son to watch movies laden with violence, abuse towards women and children or a barrage of negative language. That said, I didn't find this film to be all that threatening. It won't be appropiate for him until he's quite a bit older, but not because the author of the film is an atheist. On a personal level, I hope my own child does question his own faith one day, because than he'll know it's really his. And honestly? I view "The Matrix" as being more
anti-God than any other film I've ever seen and that one was celebrated by just about everyone. I could sooner name dozens Hollywood writers and directors who don't believe in God, are pushing their own anti-moral, anti-faith agenda in everything that they do, before I could name an ample number of writers or directors who's goal it is to focus on faith based values in main stream media.

I wouldn't normally go into my personal beliefs on a film, but I felt like a dialogue of sorts had been started in your review. It's cool you don't like sci-fi, Cam. Just like it's cool that I don't much care for Westerns or country music. And for the record, "The Never Ending Story" and "Willow" are two of the greatest family movies ever made, "Labrinyth" made me question my love for David Bowie, they are once again making a He-Man movie (this one without Courtney Cox) and YES, where is that Thundercats movie already??? Hey -Ohooo!

Anonymous said...

Totally disappointed with this review! I loved this movie as much I loved the book! How can you say fantasy doesn't make sense because of science. Aren't most movies based around some kind of fantasy idea...and fantasy movies don't just throw random things in. If you pay attention to the story it will all make sense. I guess if Cameron ever reviews a fantasy movie again I'll just have to skip that one since it's obvious he has no love for them so how could he give one an honest review.

Cameron's Corner said...

Dear Anonymous, did you not hear the list of exceptions to the general rule of "fantasies suck".

Here's a question: If you love fantasies so much, how can you give an honest review of one? You're biased the other direction.

I'm trying not to be a hater, but I honestly think if I saw a quality fantasy like Tom Cruises' LEGEND, my opinion would change.

Anonymous said...

I don't think you totally dislike fantasy films, Cam, I just think you dislike bad films. And that's a good thing. I have a general rule of not liking romantic comedies that have "Feeling Alright" by Joe Cocker in the trailer, but every so often I'm pleasantly surprised. It's a good rule - you just gotta stay away from what burned you in the past.